Temporal Logic in Literature

In this post I want to put some phrases from Literature and show (possible) translation to temporal logic (LTL - 1, LTL - 2).

1)
"In such terms Mr Gradgrind always mentally introduced himself, whether to his private circle of acquaintance, or to the public in general." Charles Dickens, Hard Times, Chapter 2

Let's compare these two formulas:

\(F (MrGradgrindMentallyIntroducesHimself)\)

\(G (MrGradgrindMentallyIntroducesHimself)\)

The first one indicates that there is one state in the future in which Mr. Gradgrind mentally introduces himself. The second one indicates that this occurs at every state, matching the keyword always in the sentence.

2)
"There will be the noise of the blows of the whip, which they will give to the horses." Alexandre Dumas, The forty-Five Guardsmen, Chapter 1

Let's compare these two formulas:

\(F\ noiseBlowsOfWhip \land F\ whipToHorses\)

\(F (noiseBlowsOfWhip \land whipToHorses)\)

The first one indicates that there is a state in the future in which there is the noise of the blows of the whip, and there is state in the future in which they whip the horses, while the second one indicates a state in the future in which both things occur. Since we know that both things are related, the whip causes the noise, we know they must be at the same state, and the second formula is preciser.

3)
' This proposal met with general applause, until an old mouse got up and said: "That is all very well, but who is to bell the Cat?" ' Aesop, Aesop's fables, Belling the Cat

A first attempt could to be to write the following formula:

\(Applause \land OldMouseQuestion\)

However, this formula expresses that at the first instant of time both things occur, and the applause may happen later and even later the question. Thus, we may attempt to correct the formula as follows:

\(Applause \land F\ OldMouseQuestion\)

It is better in that it expresses that first the applause occurs and sometime in the future the question by the old mouse. However, the applause goes only to be interrupted by the old mouse (keyword: until). Then we correct it as follows:

\(Applause\ U\ OldMouseQuestion\)

Here represents that the applause goes on until the old mouse asks its question. The only ambiguous part that remains is whether the story starts with the applause or this happens at some moment in the future. Due to our additional knowledge that first there is a discussion, then the proposal to bell the cat and only then the applause, we know that this part does not occur at the first state:

\(F\ Applause\ U\ OldMouseQuestion\)